Comparing the Effectiveness of Solution-Focused Narrative Therapy and Solution-Focused Therapy on Resilience and Marital Intimacy of Couples in Conflict (Counseling Centers of Shirvan County)

Goldasteh  Faraydoni Golyan; Maryam  Sadeghifard; Emad  Yosefi

doi:10.61838/kman.hn.3.1.4

Authors

Goldasteh Faraydoni Golyan PhD Student, Department of Psychology and Educational Science, Qeshm Branch, Islamic Azad University, Qeshm, Iran

Maryam Sadeghifard * Assistant Professor, Department of Counseling, University of Hormozgan, Bandar Abbas, Iran sadeghim45@yahoo.com

Emad Yosefi Assistant Professor, Department of Psychology and Educational Science, Qeshm Branch, Islamic Azad University, Qeshm, Iran

https://doi.org/10.61838/kman.hn.3.1.4

Keywords:

solution-focused narrative therapy, solution-focused therapy, resilience, marital intimacy, couples in conflict

Abstract

The present study aimed to compare the effects of solution-focused narrative therapy and solution-focused therapy on resilience and marital intimacy among couples in conflict. This research employed a quasi-experimental design with a pre-test, post-test, and control group, along with a two-month follow-up. The statistical population consisted of all couples experiencing marital conflict who referred to counseling centers in Shirvan County during 2022-2023. The study sample included 30 couples (20 participants in each group) with marital conflict who were selected using convenience sampling from clinics and counseling centers in Shirvan County and randomly assigned to two experimental and one control group. Solution-Focused Narrative Therapy (SFNT) and Solution-Focused Therapy (SFT) were administered separately over six sessions for the experimental groups, while the control group received no intervention. Data collection instruments included the Bagarozi Marital Intimacy Questionnaire (2001) and the Connor-Davidson Resilience Scale (2003). Collected data were analyzed using repeated measures analysis of variance and Bonferroni post hoc tests, with SPSS-26 software. Results indicated that both solution-focused narrative therapy and solution-focused therapy were effective in improving resilience and marital intimacy among couples in conflict (p < .001). Additionally, Bonferroni test results revealed that the therapeutic effects of both approaches on resilience and marital intimacy were maintained after two months (p < .001). Moreover, findings demonstrated that solution-focused narrative therapy had a greater impact on resilience and marital intimacy compared to solution-focused therapy (p < .001). Based on these results, both approaches can be used to resolve marital conflict, although solution-focused narrative therapy showed greater effectiveness than solution-focused therapy.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

1. Surijah EA, Murray K, Wraith D, Shochet I. Examining trajectories of marital satisfaction to represent the resilience process among Indonesian married individuals. Personal Relationships. 2024;31(1):24-43. [DOI]

2. Arvin N, Namjoo A, Mousavikhoo SL, Namjoo F, Keshavarz S. Exploring the Role of Family Resilience in Predicting Marital Functioning: A Cross-Sectional Study. Journal of Psychosociological Research in Family and Culture. 2024;2(1):10-5. [DOI]

3. Lawrence TI. Parental support, marital conflict, and stress as predictors of depressive symptoms among African American adolescents. Clinical Child Psychology and Psychiatry. 2022;27(3):630-43. [PMID: 35200051] [DOI]

4. Salah MM, Shekari E, Hassani H, Salehi A. Prediction of Marital Conflicts Based on Mindfulness in Couples Facing Extra-Marital Relationships Attending Counseling Centers in Fars Province. Transactions on Data Analysis in Social Science. 2024;6(1):1-13.

5. Cribbet MR, Smith TW, Uchino BN, Baucom BRW, Nealey-Moore JB. Autonomic influences on heart rate during marital conflict: Associations with high frequency heart rate variability and cardiac preejection period. Biological Psychology. 2020;151:107-12. [PMID: 31962138] [DOI]

6. Li X, Liu Q. Parent-grandparent coparenting relationship, marital conflict and parent-child relationship in Chinese parent-grandparent coparenting families. Children and Youth Services Review. 2020;109:104-10. [DOI]

7. Özgüç S, Tanrıverdi D. Relations Between Depression Level and Conflict Resolution Styles, Marital Differentiations of Patients With Major Depression and Their Spouses. Archives of Psychiatric Nursing. 2018;32(3):337-42. [PMID: 29784211] [DOI]

8. Frankel LA, Umemura T, Jacobvitz D, Hazen N. Marital conflict and parental responses to infant negative emotions: Relations with toddler emotional regulation. Infant Behavior and Development. 2015;40:73-83. [PMID: 26047678] [DOI]

9. Bagarozzi DA. Enhancing intimacy in marriage. New York: Taylor & Francis Publication; 2001.

10. Atapour N, Darbani SA. Cultural Dynamics in Couple Therapy: Enhancing Marital Intimacy Through Tailored Interventions. Journal of Psychosociological Research in Family and Culture. 2024;2(1):4-9.

11. Stulhofer A, Ferreira L, Landripet I. Emotional intimacy, sexual desire, and sexual satisfaction among partnered heterosexual men. Sexual and Relationship Therapy. 2014;17:229-44. [DOI]

12. Weinberger MI, Hofstein Y, Whitbouren SK. Intimacy in young adulthood as a predictor of divorce in midlife. Personal Relationships. 2008;15(4):551-7. [PMID: 19956778] [PMCID: PMC2733523] [DOI]

13. Asgari A, Goodarzi K. Effectiveness of Emotional Schema Therapy on Marital Intimacy among Couples on the Brink of Divorce. SALĀMAT-I IJTIMĀĪ (Community Health). 2019;6(2):174-85. [DOI]

14. Neill JT. Adventure Education and Resilience: The Double Edged Sword. Journal of Adventure Education and Outdoor Learning. 2006;1:35-42. [DOI]

15. Conway L, Wolverson E, Clarke C. Shared Experiences of Resilience Amongst Couples Where One Partner Is Living With Dementia-A Grounded Theory Study. Frontiers in Medicine. 2020;7:219. [PMID: 32582728] [PMCID: PMC7296104] [DOI]

16. Beckman CM, Stanko TL. It takes three: Relational boundary work, resilience, and commitment among navy couples. Academy of Management Journal. 2020;63(2):411-39. [DOI]

17. Beach SRH, Lei MK, Lavner JA, Adesogan O, Carter S, Barton AW. Strengthening Couple Functioning Promotes Resilience to COVID-19-related Stressors Among Black Americans. Journal of Family Psychology. 2023. [PMID: 37053419] [PMCID: PMC10238637] [DOI]

18. Senger AR. Hope's relationship with resilience and mental health during the COVID-19 pandemic. Current Opinion in Psychology. 2023;50:101559. [PMID: 36812769] [PMCID: PMC9886565] [DOI]

19. Mohammadiyari A, Hosseinian S. Meta-Analysis of the Effectiveness of Solution-Focused Short-Term Therapy on Couple Therapy. Cultural-Educational Journal of Women and Family. 2018;13(43):33-52.

20. Alavi SH, Ghasemi Motlagh M, Esmaeili Shad B, Bakhshipour A. The effectiveness of solution-focused therapy on emotional, cognitive, motivational and biological symptoms of major depressive disorder in men and women. Journal of Adolescent and Youth Psychological Studies (JAYPS). 2022;3(1):253-65. [DOI]

21. Afshar Shandiz H. Comparison of the Effectiveness of Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy (MBCT) and Short-Term Solution-Focused Therapy as Complementary Treatments with Medication in Improving the Quality of Life of Patients with Multiple Sclerosis (MS): Semnan University, Faculty of Psychology and Educational Sciences; 2023.

22. Xinhe Z, Xiaoxuan S, Shuowei X, Jingwen Q, Qinghua H, Turel O. The Effect of Solution-Focused Group Counseling Intervention on college students Internet addiction: A pilot study. MDPI International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health. 2020;17(7). [PMID: 32272623] [PMCID: PMC7178016] [DOI]

23. Arslan U, Gumuscaglayan G. Solution Focused Brief Therapy: A Brief Overview. University Journal of Education Faculty. 2018;47:491-507.

24. Arslan U, Ulus IC. Solution Focused Brief Therapy Training. Bartin University Journal of Faculty of Education. 2020;9(1):1-12. [DOI]

25. Cortes B, Basllesteros A, Collantes I, Aguilar ML. What makes for good outcomes in solution-focused brief therapy? European Psychiatry. 2016;33:222-33. [DOI]

26. Karahan FS, Bakalım O, Yoleri S. Solution focused thinking and empathy in education faculty students. Journal of Human Sciences. 2017;14(4):4383-92. [DOI]

27. Khalili G, Zehrakar K, Kasaei Esfahani A. Comparison of the Effectiveness of Solution-Focused and Rational-Emotive Behavioral Short-Term Therapy on Work Meaning in Oil Company Employees. Psychological Sciences. 2020;19(90):699-713.

28. Banisafar A, Ahi Q, Mansouri A, Bahrainian A. Comparison of the Effectiveness of Online Narrative Therapy and Cognitive Behavioral Therapy on Mental Health and Adherence to Treatment in Cancer Patients with Low Psychological Hardiness. Journal of Assessment and Research in Applied Counseling (JARAC). 2023;5(5):100-7. [DOI]

29. Boostani-Kashani A-A, Khodabakhshi-Koolaee A, Davoodi H, Heidari H. The Effect of Narrative Therapy on Communication Skills, Emotional Expression and Empathy among Couples Intending to Marry. SALĀMAT-I IJTIMĀĪ (Community Health). 2021;8(2):232-46. [DOI]

30. Kiani F. The Effectiveness of Narrative Therapy on Body Checking and Disordered Eating Behaviors in Female Adolescents. International Journal of Pediatrics. 2023;11(5):17780-9. [DOI]

31. Samaeelvand N, Sadeghi M, Ghadampour E. Comparison of Effectiveness of Integrated Models of Attachment Narrative Therapy and Unified Transdiagnostic on Cognitive Emotion Regulation Strategies in Distressed Couples. Family Counseling and Psychotherapy. 2023;13(1):37-74. [DOI]

32. Metcalf L. Solution Focused Narrative Therapy: Springer Publishing Company; 2017. [DOI]

33. Asmakhani Akbarinejad H, Ghamari M, Pouyamansh J, Fathi Aghdam G. Comparison of the Effectiveness of Narrative Therapy and Rational-Emotive Behavior Therapy on Resilience in Women with Breast Surgery Experience. Iranian Breast Diseases Quarterly. 2019;12(4):52-63. [DOI]

34. Taheri Fard A, Javidan M, Samavi SA, Najarpourian S. Effectiveness of Solution-Focused Narrative Therapy on Burnout, Enthusiasm, and Hope in Women Seeking Divorce. Applied Family Therapy Quarterly. 2023;4(4):331-49. [DOI]

35. Ball J, Mitchell P, Malhi G, Skillecorem A, Smith M. Co-constructing a Marriage: Analyses of Young Couples' Relationship Narratives. Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development. 2021;12(2):37-51.

36. Rothwell N. How brief is solution-focused brief therapy? A comparative study. Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy. 2005;12(5):402-5. [DOI]

37. Payne M. Couple Counseling: A Practical Guide to Narrative Therapy. Tehran: Arjmand Publications; 2010.

38. Yanaradag MZ, Ozmete A. The effect of solution-focused work intervention on college students' hope and stress levels. Journal Of Economic Administrative Sciences Faculty. 2020.

39. D Abate DA. Use of solution-focused and family narrative approaches in working with high-conflict families. Journal of Child Custody. 2016;13(4):269-88. [DOI]

40. Namani E, Shirashiani A. Effectiveness of Combining Solution-Focused and Narrative Therapy on Vitality and Emotional Control in Women Seeking Divorce. Counseling Culture and Psychotherapy. 2016;7(27):149-69.

41. Khamseh A, Hosseinian S. Gender Differences in Various Dimensions of Intimacy Among Married Students. Women's Studies Journal. 2017;10:35-52.

42. Jowkar B. The mediating role of resilience in the relationship between general and emotional intelligence and life satisfaction. Journal of Contemporary Psychology. 2008;2(4):3-12.

43. Mohammadi M. The effective factors on resistance in the people with the risk of substance abuse. Dissertation. 2005.

44. Rostami M, Saadati N, Yousefi Z. Comparison of Emotionally Focused and Solution-Focused Couple Therapy on Reducing Fear of Intimacy and Increasing Sexual Satisfaction in Couples. Applied Counseling. 2018;8(2):1-22.

45. Walsh-Dilley M, Wolford W, McCarthy J. Rights for resilience: food sovereignty, power, and resilience in development practice. Ecology and Society. 2016;21(1):11. [DOI]

46. Yoo H, Bartle-Haring S, Day RD, Gangamma R. Couple communication, emotional and sexual intimacy, and relationship satisfaction. Journal of Sex & Marital Therapy. 2014;40(4):93-275. [PMID: 24111536] [DOI]

47. Deshazer S. Clues: Investigating Solution in Brief Therapy. New York: Norton; 1998.

48. Kim JS, Brook J, Akin BA. Solution-focused brief therapy with substance-using individuals: A randomized controlled trial study. Research on Social Work Practice. 2018;28(4):452-62. [DOI]

49. Johnson DJ, Holyoak D, Cravens Pickens J. Using Narrative Therapy in the Treatment of Adult Survivors of Childhood Sexual Abuse in the Context of Couple Therapy. American Journal of Family Therapy. 2019;47(4):31-216. [DOI]